Romantic movies often thrive on grand gestures, sweeping soundtracks, and happy ever afters, right? Wrong. What happens when love isn’t the answer, but rather the question? Some romance films dare to explore something different: narratives that strip romance down to its most vulnerable core, where passion can sour into resentment, and forever is a promise that is hard to keep.
From the slow unraveling of a marriage to the quiet ache of unrequited love, these films prove that sometimes the most powerful stories are the ones that aren’t told with the same enthusiasm, delivering some of the most thought-provoking and engaging narratives (especially for those who aren’t fans of traditional romance tales). To celebrate this unconventional take on the genre, we look back at some of the most unromantic romance films, ranked for their ability to challenge expectations and break viewers’ hearts.
10
‘Her’ (2013)
Directed by Spike Jonze
While Spike Jonze‘s Her may technically be a love story, it trades traditional romance for a soft, digital pain. In the movie, Joaquin Phoenix plays a man who falls for his AI assistant, voiced by Scarlett Johansson, while struggling to make sense of his past relationship and ultimate divorce.
While romantic in theory, Her is deeply unromantic in practice; it is mostly a thought-provoking meditation about loneliness and the desire to feel loved, with an alienated man at its center. By exploring intimacy through absence and connection through code, Her offers a chilling portrayal of longing rather than love, and explores how tech gives us the illusion of closeness while keeping us isolated.
Her
- Release Date
-
December 18, 2013
- Runtime
-
126 Minutes
9
‘500 Days of Summer’ (2009)
Directed by Mark Webb
The romantic comedy for those who aren’t usually into the genre, 500 Days of Summer, builds itself like a love story, but the fine print says otherwise. What unfolds is a structured postmortem of a relationship with an unreliable narrator (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) and a dream girl (Zooey Deschanel) at its center.
Although Summer never claimed she was, Tom saw her as his soulmate. The heartbreak in the movie is not that love fades, but the reminder that projection isn’t love, timing matters, and people aren’t puzzles to be solved. At its core, 500 Days of Summer proves that sometimes the most seemingly fated connections are also the most mismatched, and just because you don’t end up with a person, it doesn’t make their presence in your life any less seismic.
8
‘Lost in Translation’ (2003)
Directed by Sofia Coppola
Set in the glowing city of Tokyo, the film follows two lonely Americans — Scarlett Johansson as a young woman adrift in her marriage, and Bill Murray as a faded movie star — who find a fleeting but touching connection in the space between their disillusionments. While there is clear chemistry between the two, it’s not the kind that leads to declarations or grand gestures. Instead, it entices audiences into their quiet introspectiveness, with their bond unfolding in silence and glances.
In Lost in Translation, nothing happens, yet everything does. They don’t sleep together, they don’t make plans, and they don’t have an inherently romantic relationship. While that may be what makes the movie unromantic through the lens of some, it is also what makes it deeply affecting. By resisting resolution and letting the ache linger, the Sofia Coppola-directed tale about emotional intimacy stays with audiences long after the credits roll.
7
‘A Ghost Story’ (2017)
Directed by David Lowery
Although technically about love, David Lowery‘s movie is filtered through the quiet grief that is left behind. When a man dies and becomes a ghost (a haunting Casey Affleck, literally draped in a white sheet), he gets stuck haunting the home he once shared with his partner (Rooney Mara), watches her grieve and move on.
What’s unromantic about A Ghost Story is its unsparing look at impermanence and how love doesn’t exactly survive death, at least in the context of relationships. There is no closure or reunion, just painfully long goodbyes and existential dread. For those who enjoy melancholic watches that delve into grief, loss, and love, the cosmic A Ghost Story is a visually striking must-see that will not disappoint slow-burn enthusiasts.
A Ghost Story
- Release Date
-
April 24, 2017
- Director
-
David Lowery
- Writers
-
David Lowery
6
‘Never Let Me Go’ (2010)
Directed by Mark Romanek
A love story trapped inside a dystopian nightmare, Mark Romanek‘s Never Let Me Go follows clones raised for the sole purpose of organ donation as they fall into painfully human behavior, including longing, jealousy, and tender connection. The love triangle at its core is muted and restrained, but what truly makes the movie unromantic is how little the romance can do.
In Never Let Me Go, love doesn’t offer escape or rebellion; it only adds sorrow to the inevitable. Although the movie is undeniably engaging and thought-provoking, the story is stripped of fantasy, portraying love as something deeply human and powerless. The most its characters can hope for is a brief delay in their sentences and a few more days together.
5
‘Marriage Story’ (2019)
Directed by Noah Baumbach
Starring Scarlett Johansson and Adam Driver, Noah Baumbach‘s Marriage Story is the kind of movie that begins where most romantic films end. Charlie and Nicole are already splitting up when we meet them, and the movie traces their bi-coastal divorce and subsequent custody battle with painful precision, whether it’s the legal tension or moments of tenderness.
It’s not Marriage Story‘s lack of feeling that makes it unromantic; it’s its refusal to glorify love and toxic relationships, and the way it depicts it as something that sometimes can’t survive the realities of ambition, parenting, and even miscommunication. Baumbach doesn’t shy away from depicting how relationships can be eroded by ambition, parenting challenges, and the everyday failures of miscommunication.
4
‘Revolutionary Road’ (2008)
Directed by Sam Mendes
Following Frank and April Wheeler (Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet in their second collaboration after the iconic Titanic), Sam Mendes‘ Revolutionary Road illustrates a young couple in 1950s suburban Connecticut whose seemingly perfect marriage begins to fall apart. While their plan to escape to Paris sparks hope, they are quickly smothered by unwanted pregnancy and mutual betrayals.
Revolutionary Road does not shy away from stripping away the Hollywood illusion of love. Rather than glamorizing every aspect of relationships, it exposes the devastating consequences of miscommunication and the cost of lost dreams. Despite being labeled as a romance film, it’s evident that this Sam Mendes movie fully transforms its premise into a haunting portrayal of disillusionment and frustration, the utter destruction of the American Dream.
3
‘Closer’ (2004)
Directed by Mike Nichols
The perfect pick for those who enjoy indie slice-of-life with a bit of romance, Closer is a must-watch drama. It follows the tangled relationships of four Londoners — Alice (Natalie Portman), Dan (Jude Law), Anna (Julia Roberts), and Larry (Clive Owen) — as their lives intersect through chance encounters and changing desires.
Like Revolutionary Road, Closer being marked as a romance is not inherently wrong. However, the movie is not for casual romance enthusiasts, as they can expect to step onto an emotional battlefield instead of finding a safe haven. With a brutally honest focus on passion, heartbreak, and attraction, Mike Nichols’ movie illustrates how relationships are often marked by dishonesty and jealousy, earning its place among the most unromantic romance films by exposing the toxic side of modern relationships.
Closer
- Release Date
-
December 3, 2004
- Runtime
-
104 Minutes
2
‘Leaving Las Vegas’ (1995)
Directed by Mike Figgis
The kind of love story that shatters the mold and then sweeps the shards into a shot glass, Mike Figgis‘ Leaving Las Vegas follows Nicolas Cage‘s Ben Sanderson (his Oscar-winning role), a Hollywood screenwriter whose self-destructive spiral leads him to Las Vegas with one goal: drink himself to the point of no return. But then he meets Sera (Elisabeth Shue), a sex worker who turns out to be the only person who can truly see him.
Leaving Las Vegas‘ brutal honesty sets it apart from traditional romances; there are no grand gestures or promises of forever. Instead, it offers a love story that is built on the acceptance of brokenness and the absence of a “fix.” With hyper-realistic performances at its center, Figgis’ movie depicts love without illusions, making for the perfect pick for those who prefer their romance unromantic.
1
‘Blue Valentine’ (2010)
Directed by Derek Cianfrance
Derek Cianfrance‘s Blue Valentine feels like a cold shower after a hangover: uncomfortable but brutally clarifying. Starring Michelle Williams and Ryan Gosling in two powerhouse performances, it traces the slow, excruciating unraveling of a marriage with as much tenderness as it does pain. The movie flips between Dean and Cindy’s early days and their present, where love has curdled into resentment and disappointment.
Blue Valentine is in a league of its own because it refuses to cast blame or feed melodrama. The chemistry between the two leads is undeniable, but so is their incompatibility. At its core, this Cianfrance film is a reminder that sometimes love isn’t enough to bridge the gap between who we are and who we wish we could be, especially for each other, and in the context of a relationship.
Blue Valentine
- Release Date
-
December 29, 2010
- Runtime
-
112 Minutes
- Director
-
Derek Cianfrance